It looks like Royal watchers aren’t done sniffing out that rumored feud between Kate Middleton and Meghan Markle. Despite reports that the two have become gal pals now that Meghan is a mom, fans are still trying to find shade between the two.

We told you before that Sunday was Meghan’s birthday. Kate and Prince William wished her a happy birthday with a post to their Kensington Royal account, alongside a pick of the Royal “Fab Four” walking together. The birthday message was perfectly sweet, but the choice of photo alone was enough to stir up fans.

In the comments, some Instagrammers are saying it’s strange that they didn’t choose a picture of Meghan alone… which seems like a stretch. Others don’t like that Meghan doesn’t stand out among the group while Kate does in a bright red outfit. Basically, some fans are calling Kate’s b-day message shady.